Connecting every commercial decision from customer enquiry to commissioning and financial close
I have lost count of the times I have explained this simple principle to varied stakeholders involved in the delivery of a construction project.
The Commercial Thread through the project lifecycle
| Stage | Principal’s commercial objective | Key methods / skills | Commercial Thread output |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Enquiry / Need | Understand what the customer actually requires and why | Requirements definition, stakeholder management, scope development | Statement of need |
| 2. Feasibility | Determine whether the project is technically, commercially and financially viable | Option analysis, benchmarking, risk assessment, constructability, early estimating | Preferred option + feasibility estimate |
| 3. Concept Design | Define enough scope to establish a defensible cost and risk position | Design management, value engineering, cost planning, schedule development | Concept baseline |
| 4. Cost Planning | Understand what the project should cost before asking the market | Quantity take-offs, first-principles estimating, benchmarking, escalation, contingency analysis | Principal’s cost plan / estimate |
| 5. Procurement Strategy | Decide how the market should be engaged and where each risk should sit | Market analysis, packaging, risk allocation, contracting strategy | Procurement and contracting strategy |
| 6. Tender Documentation | Ensure the market prices exactly what the Principal intends to buy | Scope writing, specifications, drawings, BoQ/pricing schedules, commercial conditions | Tender baseline |
| 7. Tender Evaluation | Establish what each tenderer has actually priced and excluded | Tender normalisation, clarification, commercial/technical evaluation, risk pricing | Evaluated tender position |
| 8. Contract Award | Convert the tender into an enforceable commercial baseline | Contract drafting, scope reconciliation, departure closure, negotiation | Contract baseline |
| 9. Construction | Ensure expenditure remains consistent with contractual entitlement and approved scope | Cost control, scheduling, forecasting, change control, claims management, contract administration | Current approved forecast |
| 10. Commissioning | Prove the asset performs as contracted | Testing, verification, defect management, completion certification | Verified operational asset |
| 11. Handover | Confirm the Principal received what it paid for | Asset records, as-builts, warranties, manuals, training, completion documentation | Accepted asset |
| 12. Commercial Close | Establish the final contractual and financial position | Final account, claims settlement, reconciliation, release of securities | Final commercial position |
| 13. Lessons Learnt | Feed actual performance back into the next project | Estimate reconciliation, productivity analysis, benchmarking and lessons learned | Better future estimates and contracts |
At any point in the project lifecycle, can the project team clearly explain:
- what is being delivered, and what it should cost;
- what assumptions were made;
- what risks the Principal carries;
- what the contractor is obligated to deliver;
- what has changed and why; and
- what is the final outcome now expected to be.
If the answer is yes, the Commercial Thread is intact.
If the answer is no, the project may still appear to be progressing, but commercial control is already weakening or worse still, it has failed